Boston College Law Review
Skip to main content
Boston College Law Review
Home
>
JOURNALS
>
BCLR
>
Vol. 59
>
Iss. 2 (2018)
Article Title
The Admissibility of Sampling Evidence to Prove Individual Damages in Class Actions
Document Type
Article
Abstract
The 2016 Supreme Court decision in Tyson Foods, Inc. v. Bouaphakeo revived the use of “representative” or sampling evidence in class actions. Federal courts are now more receptive to class plaintiffs’ efforts to prove classwide liability and, occasionally, aggregate damages, with sampling evidence. However, federal courts still routinely deny motions for class certification because they find that calculations of class members’ individual damages defeat the predominance prerequisite of Rule 23(b)(3). As a result, meritorious classwide claims founder. In this paper, we combine legal and statistical analyses and propose a novel solution to this dilemma that adheres to the Tyson decision while satisfying Daubert, the standards of Federal Rule of Evidence 702, and the prerequisites for Rule 23(b)(3) classes. We develop a method and derive a threshold to determine whether class damages claims are sufficiently homogeneous to justify the admissibility of sampling evidence to prove individual damages. Relying on Daubert and its progeny, as well as other well-recognized authority, we argue that accuracy is an appropriate standard for evidentiary reliability. Then, using generally accepted statistical methods and standards, we show that, when judgment variability exceeds claim variability (terms we define), sampling evidence improves accuracy and evidentiary reliability and is, therefore, admissible in Rule 23(b)(3) class certification proceedings. We also recommend several procedures to evaluate whether damages claims of a putative class satisfy the derived threshold. We conclude that our proposed method to prove individual damages achieves the Supreme Court’s stated goals of Rule 23(b)(3) class actions, “economies of time, effort, and expense” and the promotion of “uniformity of decision as to persons similarly situated, without sacrificing procedural fairness or bringing about other undesirable results.”
Recommended Citation
Hillel J. Bavli & John K. Felter,
The Admissibility of Sampling Evidence to Prove Individual Damages in Class Actions,
59
B.C.L. Rev.
655
(2018),
https://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/bclr/vol59/iss2/5
insertDownloads(11672717);
// bind to event when PlumX widget loads
jQuery('body').bind('plum:widget-load', function(e){
// if Plum badge is visible
if (jQuery('.PlumX-Popup').length) {
// remove 'hidden' class
jQuery('#article-stats').removeClass('hidden');
jQuery('.article-stats-date').addClass('plum-border');
}
});
// bind to event when page loads
jQuery(window).bind('load',function(e){
// if DC downloads are visible
if (jQuery('#article-downloads').text().length > 0) {
// add border to aside
jQuery('#article-stats').removeClass('hidden');
}
});
$(function() {
// This is the handler for Plum popup engagement on mouseover
$("#article-stats").on("mouseover", "a.plx-wrapping-print-link", function(event) {
// Send the event to Amplitude
amplitude.getInstance().logEvent("plumPopupMouseover");
});
// This is the handler for Plum badge and 'see details' link clickthrough
$("#article-stats").on("click", "div.ppp-container.ppp-small.ppp-badge", function(event) {
// Send the event to Amplitude
amplitude.getInstance().logEvent("plumDetailsClick");
});
// This is the handler for AddThis link clickthrough
$(".addthis_toolbox").on("click", "a", function(event) {
// Send the event to Amplitude
amplitude.getInstance().logEvent("addThisClick");
});
// This is the handler for AddThis link clickthrough
$(".aside.download-button").on("click", "a", function(event) {
// Send the event to Amplitude
amplitude.getInstance().logEvent("downloadClick");
});
});
Included in
Consumer Protection Law Commons,
Evidence Commons,
Torts Commons
COinS
(function(i,s,o,g,r,a,m){i['GoogleAnalyticsObject']=r;i[r]=i[r]||function(){
(i[r].q=i[r].q||).push(arguments)},i[r].l=1*new Date();a=s.createElement(o),
m=s.getElementsByTagName(o)[0];a.async=1;a.src=g;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)
})(window,document,'script','https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js','ga');
ga('create', 'UA-10184710-47', 'auto');
ga('create', 'UA-9893151-12', 'auto', {'name': 'newTracker'}); // Admin tracker.
ga('send', 'pageview');
ga('newTracker.send', 'pageview'); // Send page view for admin tracker.
BPBootstrap.init({appendCookie:''})
