The Gold Glove Award given to Eric Chavez for his performance during the 2005 season

The Rawlings Gold Glove Award, usually referred to as the Gold Glove, is the award given annually to the Major League Baseball players judged to have exhibited superior individual fielding performances at each fielding position in both the National League (NL) and the American League (AL), as voted by the managers and coaches in each league.^[1] It is also awarded to women fastpitch softball players in the National Pro Fastpitch as of 2016.^[2] Managers are not permitted to vote for their own players.^[1] Additionally, a sabermetric component provided by Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) accounts for approximately 25 percent of the vote.^[3] Eighteen Gold Gloves are awarded each year (with the exception of 1957, 1985, 2007, and 2018), one at each of the nine positions in each league. In 1957, the baseball glove manufacturer Rawlings created the Gold Glove Award to commemorate the best fielding performance at each position.^[4] The award was created from a glove made from gold lamé-tanned leather and affixed to a walnut base.^[5] Initially, only one Gold Glove per position was awarded to the top fielder at each position in Major League Baseball;^[4] however, separate awards were given for the National and American Leagues beginning in 1958.^[6][7]

History[edit]

For the first four seasons of the award (1957 to 1960), individual awards were presented to left fielders, center fielders, and right fielders. From 1961 through 2010, the phrase "at each position" was no longer strictly accurate, since the prize was presented to three outfielders irrespective of their specific position.^[8] Any combination of outfielders, often three center fielders, could win the award in the same year.^[9][10] Critics called for awarding a single Gold Glove for each individual outfield position, arguing that the three outfield positions are not equivalent defensively.^[10] Starting in 2011, separate awards for each outfield position were once again presented.^[9] In the 1985 American League voting, a tie for third-place resulted in the presentation of Gold Glove Awards to four outfielders (Dwayne Murphy, Gary Pettis, Dwight Evans and Dave Winfield); this scenario was repeated in the National League in 2007 (Andruw Jones, Carlos Beltrán, Aaron Rowand, and Jeff Francoeur).

Before SABR's involvement in the voting process, The Boston Globe writer Peter Abraham said the Fielding Bible Awards "are far more accurate (and accountable)" than the Gold Glove awards since statistics are used along with the opinions of an expert panel. The Gold Gloves are selected by managers and coaches that may have seen a player as few as six times during the season.^[11] Bill Chuck of Comcast SportsNet New England wrote that Gold Glove voters frequently counted only errors to determine winners.^[12] Geoff Baker of The Seattle Times said the votes for the Gold Gloves rely largely on a player's past reputation.^[13] The Associated Press wrote that "some fans have viewed the Gold Gloves as mostly a popularity contest, even suggesting that a player's performance at the plate helped draw extra attention to his glove."^[14] After winning the AL Gold Glove at first base in both 1997 and 1998, Rafael Palmeiro won again in 1999 with the Texas Rangers while only appearing in 28 games as a first baseman; he played in 128 games as a designated hitter that season, resulting in a controversy.^{[12][15][16][17]}Derek Jeter, winner of five Gold Gloves, believes that many defensive factors cannot be quantified.^[18] In 2013, Rawlings collaborated on the Gold Glove Award with SABR, who provided the SABR Defensive Index (SDI) to add a sabermetric component to the selection process. The index accounted for 25 percent of the vote, while managers and coaches continued to provide the majority.^[3] Afterwards, Jay Jaffe of Sports Illustrated wrote that the Gold Gloves "appear to have significantly closed the gap on their more statistically-driven counterparts."^[19] SABR and FiveThirtyEight believed that the impact to the voting results by SDI, which is also included on the voters' ballots, went beyond its 25 own percent weight and also influenced the managers' and coaches' voting.^[20]

The most Gold Gloves ever won by one player is 18 by pitcher Greg Maddux. He won 13 consecutive awards from 1990 to 2002, all in the National League.^[21]Brooks Robinson has the most wins as a third baseman, with 16 Gold Gloves,^[22] and is tied for the second-highest total overall with pitcher Jim Kaat, who won his 16 awards consecutively.^[23]Iván Rodríguez has won the most Gold Gloves as a catcher, with 13 career awards in the American League.^[24]Ozzie Smith has 13 wins at shortstop; he and Rodríguez are tied for the fourth-highest total among all winners.^[25] Among outfielders, Roberto Clemente and Willie Mays, who played primarily right field and center field, respectively, are tied for the lead with 12 Gold Gloves.^[26][27]Keith Hernandez, the leader at first base, has won 11 times,^[28] and Roberto Alomar leads second basemen with 10 wins.^[29] Other players with 10 or more wins include shortstop Omar Vizquel (11),^[30] catcher Johnny Bench (10),^[31] third baseman Mike Schmidt (10),^[32] and outfielders Ken Griffey Jr., Ichiro Suzuki, Andruw Jones, and Al Kaline (10 each).^{[33][34][35][36]}

The only player to win Gold Gloves as an infielder and outfielder is Darin Erstad, who won Gold Gloves as an outfielder in 2000 and 2002 and as a first baseman in 2004, all with the Anaheim Angels.^[37] The only other player to win Gold Gloves at multiple positions is Plácido Polanco, who won at second base (2007, 2009 AL) and third base (2011 NL).^[38] Family pairs to win Gold Gloves include brothers Ken and Clete Boyer (third base),^[39][40] brothers Sandy Alomar, Jr. (catcher) and Roberto Alomar (second base),^[29]Bengie and Yadier Molina (catcher),^[41][42] father and son Bobby and Barry Bonds (outfield),^[43][44] and father and son Bob (catcher) and Bret Boone (second base).^[45][46]

In 2016, Rawlings announced it would begin awarding a gold glove annually to a female fastpitch softball player in the National Pro Fastpitch league.^[47]
NPF coaches and managers vote for a winner (excluding those on their respective teams). This award is in addition to the collegiate and high school awards added in 2007, its 50th anniversary.^[48]

Greg Maddux won 18 Gold Gloves, the most of any player.

Winners[edit]

Key to symbols and headers in player lists

Year	Links to the corresponding Major League Baseball season
1B	First baseman (list of winners)
2B	Second baseman (list of winners)
3B	Third baseman (list of winners)
SS	Shortstop (list of winners)
OF	Outfielder[a] (list of winners)
C	Catcher (list of winners)
P	Pitcher (list of winners)
* or **	Winner of the most Gold Glove Awards at his position (** indicates tie)
	Member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum

Gold Glove winners in the American League, listed by position

Year	1B	2B	3B	SS	OF	OF	OF	C	P
1957[b]	Gil Hodges	Nellie Fox	Frank Malzone	Roy McMillan	Willie Mays**[c]	Al Kaline[d]	Minnie Miñoso[e]	Sherm Lollar	Bobby Shantz
1958	Vic Power	Frank Bolling	Frank Malzone	Luis Aparicio	Norm Siebern[e]	Al Kaline[d]	Jimmy Piersall[c]	Sherm Lollar	Bobby Shantz
1959	Vic Power	Nellie Fox	Frank Malzone	Luis Aparicio	Jackie Jensen[d]	Al Kaline[c]	Minnie Miñoso[e]	Sherm Lollar	Bobby Shantz
1960	Vic Power	Nellie Fox	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Jim Landis[c]	Roger Maris[d]	Minnie Miñoso[e]	Earl Battey	Bobby Shantz
1961	Vic Power	Bobby Richardson	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Jim Landis	Al Kaline	Jimmy Piersall	Earl Battey	Frank Lary
1962	Vic Power	Bobby Richardson	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Jim Landis	Al Kaline	Mickey Mantle	Earl Battey	Jim Kaat
1963	Vic Power	Bobby Richardson	Brooks Robinson*	Zoilo Versalles	Jim Landis	Al Kaline	Carl Yastrzemski	Elston Howard	Jim Kaat
1964	Vic Power	Bobby Richardson	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Jim Landis	Al Kaline	Vic Davalillo	Elston Howard	Jim Kaat
1965	Joe Pepitone	Bobby Richardson	Brooks Robinson*	Zoilo Versalles	Tom Tresh	Al Kaline	Carl Yastrzemski	Bill Freehan	Jim Kaat
1966	Joe Pepitone	Bobby Knoop	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Tommie Agee	Al Kaline	Tony Oliva	Bill Freehan	Jim Kaat
1967	George Scott	Bobby Knoop	Brooks Robinson*	Jim Fregosi	Paul Blair	Al Kaline	Carl Yastrzemski	Bill Freehan	Jim Kaat
1968	George Scott	Bobby Knoop	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Reggie Smith	Mickey Stanley	Carl Yastrzemski	Bill Freehan	Jim Kaat
1969	Joe Pepitone	Davey Johnson	Brooks Robinson*	Mark Belanger	Paul Blair	Mickey Stanley	Carl Yastrzemski	Bill Freehan	Jim Kaat
1970	Jim Spencer	Davey Johnson	Brooks Robinson*	Luis Aparicio	Paul Blair	Mickey Stanley	Ken Berry	Ray Fosse	Jim Kaat
1971	George Scott	Davey Johnson	Brooks Robinson*	Mark Belanger	Paul Blair	Amos Otis	Carl Yastrzemski	Ray Fosse	Jim Kaat
1972	George Scott	Doug Griffin	Brooks Robinson*	Ed Brinkman	Paul Blair	Bobby Murcer	Ken Berry	Carlton Fisk	Jim Kaat
1973	George Scott	Bobby Grich	Brooks Robinson*	Mark Belanger	Paul Blair	Amos Otis	Mickey Stanley	Thurman Munson	Jim Kaat
1974	George Scott	Bobby Grich	Brooks Robinson*	Mark Belanger	Paul Blair	Amos Otis	Joe Rudi	Thurman Munson	Jim Kaat
1975	George Scott	Bobby Grich	Brooks Robinson*	Mark Belanger	Paul Blair	Fred Lynn	Joe Rudi	Thurman Munson	Jim Kaat
1976	George Scott	Bobby Grich	Aurelio Rodríguez	Mark Belanger	Dwight Evans	Rick Manning	Joe Rudi	Jim Sundberg	Jim Palmer
1977	Jim Spencer	Frank White	Graig Nettles	Mark Belanger	Juan Beníquez	Al Cowens	Carl Yastrzemski	Jim Sundberg	Jim Palmer
1978	Chris Chambliss	Frank White	Graig Nettles	Mark Belanger	Dwight Evans	Fred Lynn	Rick Miller	Jim Sundberg	Jim Palmer
1979	Cecil Cooper	Frank White	Buddy Bell	Rick Burleson	Dwight Evans	Fred Lynn	Sixto Lezcano	Jim Sundberg	Jim Palmer
1980	Cecil Cooper	Frank White	Buddy Bell	Alan Trammell	Willie Wilson	Fred Lynn	Dwayne Murphy	Jim Sundberg	Mike Norris
1981	Mike Squires	Frank White	Buddy Bell	Alan Trammell	Dwight Evans	Rickey Henderson	Dwayne Murphy	Jim Sundberg	Mike Norris
1982	Eddie Murray	Frank White	Buddy Bell	Robin Yount	Dwight Evans	Dave Winfield	Dwayne Murphy	Bob Boone	Ron Guidry
1983	Eddie Murray	Lou Whitaker	Buddy Bell	Alan Trammell	Dwight Evans	Dave Winfield	Dwayne Murphy	Lance Parrish	Ron Guidry
1984	Eddie Murray	Lou Whitaker	Buddy Bell	Alan Trammell	Dwight Evans	Dave Winfield	Dwayne Murphy	Lance Parrish	Ron Guidry
1985	Don Mattingly	Lou Whitaker	George Brett	Alfredo Griffin	Dwight Evans	Dave Winfield & Gary Pettis	Dwayne Murphy	Lance Parrish	Ron Guidry
1986	Don Mattingly	Frank White	Gary Gaetti	Tony Fernández	Kirby Puckett	Gary Pettis	Jesse Barfield	Bob Boone	Ron Guidry
1987	Don Mattingly	Frank White	Gary Gaetti	Tony Fernández	Kirby Puckett	Dave Winfield	Jesse Barfield	Bob Boone	Mark Langston
1988	Don Mattingly	Harold Reynolds	Gary Gaetti	Tony Fernández	Kirby Puckett	Gary Pettis	Devon White	Bob Boone	Mark Langston
1989	Don Mattingly	Harold Reynolds	Gary Gaetti	Tony Fernández	Kirby Puckett	Gary Pettis	Devon White	Bob Boone	Bret Saberhagen
1990	Mark McGwire	Harold Reynolds	Kelly Gruber	Ozzie Guillén	Gary Pettis	Ellis Burks	Ken Griffey Jr.	Sandy Alomar Jr.	Mike Boddicker
1991	Don Mattingly	Roberto Alomar*	Robin Ventura	Cal Ripken Jr.	Kirby Puckett	Devon White	Ken Griffey Jr.	Tony Peña	Mark Langston
1992	Don Mattingly	Roberto Alomar*	Robin Ventura	Cal Ripken Jr.	Kirby Puckett	Devon White	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mark Langston
1993	Don Mattingly	Roberto Alomar*	Robin Ventura	Omar Vizquel	Kenny Lofton	Devon White	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mark Langston
1994	Don Mattingly	Roberto Alomar*	Wade Boggs	Omar Vizquel	Kenny Lofton	Devon White	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mark Langston
1995	J. T. Snow	Roberto Alomar*	Wade Boggs	Omar Vizquel	Kenny Lofton	Devon White	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mark Langston
1996	J. T. Snow	Roberto Alomar*	Robin Ventura	Omar Vizquel	Kenny Lofton	Jay Buhner	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mike Mussina
1997	Rafael Palmeiro	Chuck Knoblauch	Matt Williams	Omar Vizquel	Bernie Williams	Jim Edmonds	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mike Mussina
1998	Rafael Palmeiro	Roberto Alomar*	Robin Ventura	Omar Vizquel	Bernie Williams	Jim Edmonds	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mike Mussina
1999	Rafael Palmeiro	Roberto Alomar*	Scott Brosius	Omar Vizquel	Bernie Williams	Shawn Green	Ken Griffey Jr.	Iván Rodríguez*	Mike Mussina
2000	John Olerud	Roberto Alomar*	Travis Fryman	Omar Vizquel	Bernie Williams	Jermaine Dye	Darin Erstad	Iván Rodríguez*	Kenny Rogers
2001	Doug Mientkiewicz	Roberto Alomar*	Eric Chavez	Omar Vizquel	Torii Hunter	Mike Cameron	Ichiro Suzuki	Iván Rodríguez*	Mike Mussina
2002	John Olerud	Bret Boone	Eric Chavez	Alex Rodriguez	Torii Hunter	Darin Erstad	Ichiro Suzuki	Bengie Molina	Kenny Rogers
2003	John Olerud	Bret Boone	Eric Chavez	Alex Rodriguez	Torii Hunter	Mike Cameron	Ichiro Suzuki	Bengie Molina	Mike Mussina
2004	Darin Erstad	Bret Boone	Eric Chavez	Derek Jeter	Torii Hunter	Vernon Wells	Ichiro Suzuki	Iván Rodríguez*	Kenny Rogers
2005	Mark Teixeira	Orlando Hudson	Eric Chavez	Derek Jeter	Torii Hunter	Vernon Wells	Ichiro Suzuki	Jason Varitek	Kenny Rogers
2006	Mark Teixeira	Mark Grudzielanek	Eric Chavez	Derek Jeter	Torii Hunter	Vernon Wells	Ichiro Suzuki	Iván Rodríguez*	Kenny Rogers
2007	Kevin Youkilis	Plácido Polanco	Adrián Beltré	Orlando Cabrera	Torii Hunter	Grady Sizemore	Ichiro Suzuki	Iván Rodríguez*	Johan Santana
2008	Carlos Peña	Dustin Pedroia	Adrián Beltré	Michael Young	Torii Hunter	Grady Sizemore	Ichiro Suzuki	Joe Mauer	Mike Mussina
2009	Mark Teixeira	Plácido Polanco	Evan Longoria	Derek Jeter	Torii Hunter	Adam Jones	Ichiro Suzuki	Joe Mauer	Mark Buehrle
2010	Mark Teixeira	Robinson Canó	Evan Longoria	Derek Jeter	Carl Crawford	Franklin Gutiérrez	Ichiro Suzuki	Joe Mauer	Mark Buehrle
2011	Adrian Gonzalez	Dustin Pedroia	Adrián Beltré	Erick Aybar	Alex Gordon[e]	Jacoby Ellsbury[c]	Nick Markakis[d]	Matt Wieters	Mark Buehrle
2012	Mark Teixeira	Robinson Canó	Adrián Beltré	J. J. Hardy	Alex Gordon[e]	Adam Jones[c]	Josh Reddick [d]	Matt Wieters	Jeremy Hellickson & Jake Peavy
2013	Eric Hosmer	Dustin Pedroia	Manny Machado	J. J. Hardy	Alex Gordon[e]	Adam Jones[c]	Shane Victorino [d]	Salvador Pérez	R.A. Dickey
2014	Eric Hosmer	Dustin Pedroia	Kyle Seager	J. J. Hardy	Alex Gordon[e]	Adam Jones[c]	Nick Markakis[d]	Salvador Pérez	Dallas Keuchel
2015	Eric Hosmer	José Altuve	Manny Machado	Alcides Escobar	Yoenis Céspedes[e]	Kevin Kiermaier[c]	Kole Calhoun[d]	Salvador Pérez	Dallas Keuchel
2016	Mitch Moreland	Ian Kinsler	Adrián Beltré	Francisco Lindor	Brett Gardner[e]	Kevin Kiermaier[c]	Mookie Betts[d]	Salvador Pérez	Dallas Keuchel
2017	Eric Hosmer	Brian Dozier	Evan Longoria	Andrelton Simmons	Alex Gordon[e]	Byron Buxton[c]	Mookie Betts[d]	Martín Maldonado	Marcus Stroman
2018	Matt Olson	Ian Kinsler	Matt Chapman	Andrelton Simmons	Alex Gordon[e]	Jackie Bradley Jr.[c]	Mookie Betts[d]	Salvador Pérez	Dallas Keuchel

Gold Glove winners in the National League, listed by position

Year	1B	2B	3B	SS	OF	OF	OF	C	P
1957[b]	Gil Hodges	Nellie Fox	Frank Malzone	Roy McMillan	Minnie Miñoso[e]	Al Kaline[d]	Willie Mays**[c]	Sherm Lollar	Bobby Shantz
1958	Gil Hodges	Bill Mazeroski	Ken Boyer	Roy McMillan	Hank Aaron[d]	Frank Robinson[e]	Willie Mays**[c]	Del Crandall	Harvey Haddix
1959	Gil Hodges	Charlie Neal	Ken Boyer	Roy McMillan	Hank Aaron[d]	Jackie Brandt[e]	Willie Mays**[c]	Del Crandall	Harvey Haddix
1960	Bill White	Bill Mazeroski	Ken Boyer	Ernie Banks	Hank Aaron[d]	Wally Moon[e]	Willie Mays**[c]	Del Crandall	Harvey Haddix
1961	Bill White	Bill Mazeroski	Ken Boyer	Maury Wills	Vada Pinson	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Johnny Roseboro	Bobby Shantz
1962	Bill White	Ken Hubbs	Jim Davenport	Maury Wills	Bill Virdon	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Del Crandall	Bobby Shantz
1963	Bill White	Bill Mazeroski	Ken Boyer	Bobby Wine	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Johnny Edwards	Bobby Shantz
1964	Bill White	Bill Mazeroski	Ron Santo	Rubén Amaro Sr.	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Johnny Edwards	Bobby Shantz
1965	Bill White	Bill Mazeroski	Ron Santo	Leo Cárdenas	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Joe Torre	Bob Gibson
1966	Bill White	Bill Mazeroski	Ron Santo	Gene Alley	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Johnny Roseboro	Bob Gibson
1967	Wes Parker	Bill Mazeroski	Ron Santo	Gene Alley	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Randy Hundley	Bob Gibson
1968	Wes Parker	Glenn Beckert	Ron Santo	Dal Maxvill	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Willie Mays**	Johnny Bench	Bob Gibson
1969	Wes Parker	Félix Millán	Clete Boyer	Don Kessinger	Curt Flood	Roberto Clemente**	Pete Rose	Johnny Bench	Bob Gibson
1970	Wes Parker	Tommy Helms	Doug Rader	Don Kessinger	Tommie Agee	Roberto Clemente**	Pete Rose	Johnny Bench	Bob Gibson
1971	Wes Parker	Tommy Helms	Doug Rader	Bud Harrelson	Willie Davis	Roberto Clemente**	Bobby Bonds	Johnny Bench	Bob Gibson
1972	Wes Parker	Félix Millán	Doug Rader	Larry Bowa	Willie Davis	Roberto Clemente**	César Cedeño	Johnny Bench	Bob Gibson
1973	Mike Jorgensen	Joe Morgan	Doug Rader	Roger Metzger	Willie Davis	Bobby Bonds	César Cedeño	Johnny Bench	Bob Gibson
1974	Steve Garvey	Joe Morgan	Doug Rader	Dave Concepción	César Gerónimo	Bobby Bonds	César Cedeño	Johnny Bench	Andy Messersmith
1975	Steve Garvey	Joe Morgan	Ken Reitz	Dave Concepción	César Gerónimo	Garry Maddox	César Cedeño	Johnny Bench	Andy Messersmith
1976	Steve Garvey	Joe Morgan	Mike Schmidt	Dave Concepción	César Gerónimo	Garry Maddox	César Cedeño	Johnny Bench	Jim Kaat
1977	Steve Garvey	Joe Morgan	Mike Schmidt	Dave Concepción	César Gerónimo	Garry Maddox	Dave Parker	Johnny Bench	Jim Kaat
1978	Keith Hernandez*	Davey Lopes	Mike Schmidt	Larry Bowa	Ellis Valentine	Garry Maddox	Dave Parker	Bob Boone	Phil Niekro
1979	Keith Hernandez*	Manny Trillo	Mike Schmidt	Dave Concepción	Dave Winfield	Garry Maddox	Dave Parker	Bob Boone	Phil Niekro
1980	Keith Hernandez*	Doug Flynn	Mike Schmidt	Ozzie Smith*	Dave Winfield	Garry Maddox	Andre Dawson	Gary Carter	Phil Niekro
1981	Keith Hernandez*	Manny Trillo	Mike Schmidt	Ozzie Smith*	Dusty Baker	Garry Maddox	Andre Dawson	Gary Carter	Steve Carlton
1982	Keith Hernandez*	Manny Trillo	Mike Schmidt	Ozzie Smith*	Dale Murphy	Garry Maddox	Andre Dawson	Gary Carter	Phil Niekro
1983	Keith Hernandez*	Ryne Sandberg	Mike Schmidt	Ozzie Smith*	Dale Murphy	Willie McGee	Andre Dawson	Tony Peña	Phil Niekro
1984	Keith Hernandez*	Ryne Sandberg	Mike Schmidt	Ozzie Smith*	Dale Murphy	Bob Dernier	Andre Dawson	Tony Peña	Joaquín Andújar
1985	Keith Hernandez*	Ryne Sandberg	Tim Wallach	Ozzie Smith*	Dale Murphy	Willie McGee	Andre Dawson	Tony Peña	Rick Reuschel
1986	Keith Hernandez*	Ryne Sandberg	Mike Schmidt	Ozzie Smith*	Dale Murphy	Willie McGee	Tony Gwynn	Jody Davis	Fernando Valenzuela
1987	Keith Hernandez*	Ryne Sandberg	Terry Pendleton	Ozzie Smith*	Eric Davis	Andre Dawson	Tony Gwynn	Mike LaValliere	Rick Reuschel
1988	Keith Hernandez*	Ryne Sandberg	Tim Wallach	Ozzie Smith*	Eric Davis	Andre Dawson	Andy Van Slyke	Benito Santiago	Orel Hershiser
1989	Andrés Galarraga	Ryne Sandberg	Terry Pendleton	Ozzie Smith*	Eric Davis	Tony Gwynn	Andy Van Slyke	Benito Santiago	Ron Darling
1990	Andrés Galarraga	Ryne Sandberg	Tim Wallach	Ozzie Smith*	Barry Bonds	Tony Gwynn	Andy Van Slyke	Benito Santiago	Greg Maddux*
1991	Will Clark	Ryne Sandberg	Matt Williams	Ozzie Smith*	Barry Bonds	Tony Gwynn	Andy Van Slyke	Tom Pagnozzi	Greg Maddux*
1992	Mark Grace	José Lind	Terry Pendleton	Ozzie Smith*	Barry Bonds	Larry Walker	Andy Van Slyke	Tom Pagnozzi	Greg Maddux*
1993	Mark Grace	Robby Thompson	Matt Williams	Jay Bell	Barry Bonds	Larry Walker	Marquis Grissom	Kirt Manwaring	Greg Maddux*
1994	Jeff Bagwell	Craig Biggio	Matt Williams	Barry Larkin	Barry Bonds	Darren Lewis	Marquis Grissom	Tom Pagnozzi	Greg Maddux*
1995	Mark Grace	Craig Biggio	Ken Caminiti	Barry Larkin	Raúl Mondesí	Steve Finley	Marquis Grissom	Charles Johnson	Greg Maddux*
1996	Mark Grace	Craig Biggio	Ken Caminiti	Barry Larkin	Barry Bonds	Steve Finley	Marquis Grissom	Charles Johnson	Greg Maddux*
1997	J. T. Snow	Craig Biggio	Ken Caminiti	Rey Ordóñez	Barry Bonds	Larry Walker	Raúl Mondesí	Charles Johnson	Greg Maddux*
1998	J. T. Snow	Bret Boone	Scott Rolen	Rey Ordóñez	Barry Bonds	Larry Walker	Andruw Jones	Charles Johnson	Greg Maddux*
1999	J. T. Snow	Pokey Reese	Robin Ventura	Rey Ordóñez	Steve Finley	Larry Walker	Andruw Jones	Mike Lieberthal	Greg Maddux*
2000	J. T. Snow	Pokey Reese	Scott Rolen	Neifi Pérez	Steve Finley	Jim Edmonds	Andruw Jones	Mike Matheny	Greg Maddux*
2001	Todd Helton	Fernando Viña	Scott Rolen	Orlando Cabrera	Larry Walker	Jim Edmonds	Andruw Jones	Brad Ausmus	Greg Maddux*
2002	Todd Helton	Fernando Viña	Scott Rolen	Édgar Rentería	Larry Walker	Jim Edmonds	Andruw Jones	Brad Ausmus	Greg Maddux*
2003	Derrek Lee	Luis Castillo	Scott Rolen	Édgar Rentería	José Cruz Jr.	Jim Edmonds	Andruw Jones	Mike Matheny	Mike Hampton
2004	Todd Helton	Luis Castillo	Scott Rolen	César Izturis	Steve Finley	Jim Edmonds	Andruw Jones	Mike Matheny	Greg Maddux*
2005	Derrek Lee	Luis Castillo	Mike Lowell	Omar Vizquel	Bobby Abreu	Jim Edmonds	Andruw Jones	Mike Matheny	Greg Maddux*
2006	Albert Pujols	Orlando Hudson	Scott Rolen	Omar Vizquel	Mike Cameron	Carlos Beltrán	Andruw Jones	Brad Ausmus	Greg Maddux*
2007	Derrek Lee	Orlando Hudson	David Wright	Jimmy Rollins	Aaron Rowand & Jeff Francoeur	Carlos Beltrán	Andruw Jones	Russell Martin	Greg Maddux*
2008	Adrian Gonzalez	Brandon Phillips	David Wright	Jimmy Rollins	Nate McLouth	Carlos Beltrán	Shane Victorino	Yadier Molina	Greg Maddux*
2009	Adrian Gonzalez	Orlando Hudson	Ryan Zimmerman	Jimmy Rollins	Michael Bourn	Matt Kemp	Shane Victorino	Yadier Molina	Adam Wainwright
2010	Albert Pujols	Brandon Phillips	Scott Rolen	Troy Tulowitzki	Michael Bourn	Carlos González	Shane Victorino	Yadier Molina	Bronson Arroyo
2011	Joey Votto	Brandon Phillips	Plácido Polanco	Troy Tulowitzki	Gerardo Parra[e]	Matt Kemp[c]	Andre Ethier[d]	Yadier Molina	Clayton Kershaw
2012	Adam LaRoche	Darwin Barney	Chase Headley	Jimmy Rollins	Carlos González[e]	Andrew McCutchen[c]	Jason Heyward[d]	Yadier Molina	Mark Buehrle
2013	Paul Goldschmidt	Brandon Phillips	Nolan Arenado	Andrelton Simmons	Carlos González[e]	Carlos Gómez[c]	Gerardo Parra[d]	Yadier Molina	Adam Wainwright
2014	Adrian Gonzalez	DJ LeMahieu	Nolan Arenado	Andrelton Simmons	Christian Yelich[e]	Juan Lagares[c]	Jason Heyward[d]	Yadier Molina	Zack Greinke
2015	Paul Goldschmidt	Dee Gordon	Nolan Arenado	Brandon Crawford	Starling Marte[e]	A. J. Pollock[c]	Jason Heyward[d]	Yadier Molina	Zack Greinke
2016	Anthony Rizzo	Joe Panik	Nolan Arenado	Brandon Crawford	Starling Marte[e]	Ender Inciarte[c]	Jason Heyward[d]	Buster Posey	Zack Greinke
2017	Paul Goldschmidt	DJ LeMahieu	Nolan Arenado	Brandon Crawford	Marcell Ozuna[e]	Ender Inciarte[c]	Jason Heyward[d]	Tucker Barnhart	Zack Greinke
2018	Anthony Rizzo & Freddie Freeman	DJ LeMahieu	Nolan Arenado	Nick Ahmed	Corey Dickerson[e]	Ender Inciarte[c]	Nick Markakis[d]	Yadier Molina	Zack Greinke